“I Don’t Know How She Does It” lands smack in the middle of the cinematic bell curve: competent, occasionally charming, yet ultimately as overcommitted as its heroine. Awarding it three out of five stars feels just—like praising a store-bought pie that got plated nicely but never quite passes for homemade.
History & Development
Conceived in the jittery aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis, the film began as Hollywood’s attempt to re-package Allison Pearson’s 2002 bestseller for a post-recession audience suddenly obsessed with “having it all, while still affording it.” The Weinstein Company green-lit the project in 2010, tapping Aline Brosh McKenna, fresh off “The Devil Wears Prada," to graft a brisk, sitcom-ready structure onto Pearson’s droll, diary-like prose.
Director Douglas McGrath approached the adaptation with the same earnestness he once lavished on Austen and Capote, trading bonnets and biographers for diaper bags and Bloomberg terminals. Early drafts flirted with edgier satire, but test screenings steered the tone toward something safer, an all-audience, PG-13 reassurance that “busy” is basically a universal love language.
Casting, Production & Plot
Sarah Jessica Parker slides into Kate Reddy’s stilettos as though she’d hung onto Carrie Bradshaw’s shoe closet for a rainy day. Parker’s innate likability softens Kate’s chronic overscheduling, and she clicks amiably with Pierce Brosnan’s Jack Abelhammer—because if you must contemplate an emotional affair, 007-level cheekbones help. Greg Kinnear’s affable Richard steadies the domestic front, while Christina Hendricks and Olivia Munn inject much-needed banter and bite.
Principal photography unfolded in New York and Boston in early 2011, each location dressed to telegraph “upper-middle-class chaos.” Production design sprinkled visual Easter eggs—most memorably a Jean-Michel Basquiat piece looming over one dinner scene, silently appraising Kate’s life audit like a post-modern judgment day. The narrative itself sticks closely to the book’s episodic rhythms: pie charts, literal pies, feverish PowerPoint nights, and that snowballing guilt familiar to any parent who’s faked a homemade baked good.
Plot-wise, the film never strays far from its elevator pitch: investment banker-mom learns work-life equilibrium, declines dashing widower’s tempting advances, and still makes it to kindergarten on time—eventually. It’s comfort food cinema, albeit sprinkled with freeze-dried feminist seasoning instead of fresh herbs.
Reception & Legacy
Critics were not kind. Rotten Tomatoes slapped it with a withering 17 percent, lamenting its “hopelessly outdated viewpoint.” Variety panned it for “bland empowerment clichés,” while The Guardian’s Peter Bradshaw labeled it “excruciating”—an adjective normally reserved for tax audits and root canals. Audiences were gentler, handing it a respectable CinemaScore of B-, underscoring the eternal divide between people who review movies for a living and people who just wanted 90 minutes of escapist validation.
Financially, the film squeaked past its $24 million budget to a $30 million worldwide haul—enough to avoid catastrophe but not enough to fund a sequel featuring Kate Reddy mentoring her daughter through an unpaid internship. In the broader cultural ledger, its legacy rests in pop-culture footnotes: an SJP vehicle between “Sex and the City 2” and HBO’s “Divorce,” a reminder of Olivia Munn’s stealth-scene-stealing era, and a trivia tidbit linking Brosnan and Kinnear back to “The Matador.”
Still, for all its formula, the movie captured a transitional moment—one where Lean In hadn’t yet peaked and corporate America was only beginning to whisper about flexible work. Today, its depiction of “doing it all” feels retro, almost quaint—proof that we pushed the same boulder up the hill long before Slack and Zoom made juggling even noisier.
Closing Thoughts
“I Don’t Know How She Does It” may not revolutionize the working-mom narrative, but it offers a polished, gently funny mirror for anyone who has ever emailed a spreadsheet while frosting cupcakes at 2 a.m. In other words: not essential, certainly not disastrous—just three-star middle management in cinematic form.
⭐️⭐️⭐️ out of 5
#WorkLifeWhirl #BasquiatCameo #PieChartProblems #ThreeStarJuggle
No comments:
Post a Comment